Book Review – Mystics & Misfits

With untested ideals and a thirst for adventure, Christiana Peterson and her family moved to an intentional Christian farming community in the rural Midwest. It sounded like a simple and faithful way to follow Jesus, not to mention a great place to raise kids. In Mystics and Misfits, Peterson discovers that community life is never really simple and that she needs resources beyond her own to weather the anxiety and exhaustion of trying to save a dying farm and a floundering congregation. She turns to Christian mystics like Francis of Assisi, Simone Weil, and Dorothy Day to find sustenance for the everyday struggles and unique hardships of community life. With a contemplative’s spirit and poet’s eye, Peterson leads readers into an encounter with the God of the wild mystics and the weird misfits.

Mystics and Misfits: Meeting God Through St. Francis and Other Unlikely Saints
Christiana Peterson
Herald Press (VA)
Publication date: April 17th 2018

Grab a copy of Mystics and Misfits:
Goodreads   Amazon   Barnes & Noble   Book Depository   IndieBound

I must start off with an apology because there are no words to clearly share how incredibly special this book was to me and how fantastically written it is. I needed this book. Thank you, Christiana Peterson, for writing Mystics and Misfits.


When I first read the synopsis for Mystics and Misfits, I was immediately intrigued. But beyond back cover overviews and enticing cover art, this book seemed to come to me at a time when I really needed it. I’ve been looking for that “more” and “deeper” in my spiritual life. I know that I am not alone.

Mystics and Misfits is a beautifully and honestly written memoir of Christiana Peterson’s experiences in an intentional Mennonite community. She is a mother, a wife, a sister, a daughter, a friend – reaching beyond typical relationships of community and looking towards the closeness and understanding of the misfits (saints). Incredibly, Christiana’s conversations with the saints are both encouraging and inspiring. Perhaps, these conversations are even a bit of a “like goal” for myself.

Maybe many of us want to reach out to the saints – to find understanding, peace, kinship. Shouldn’t we try? After reading Mystics and Misfits, more than ever, I’m inclined to try.

Pages of stories of her own personal life (struggles and triumphs), anecdotes of the lives of saints, her own personal journey of spiritual discovery, and so many letters to her misfit friends (the saints) – this book is unlike anything I have ever read. It is heartfelt, it is thoughtful and it is so moving.

Mystics and Misfits is wildly special and belongs in my top five all-time favorite books.

I gave Mystics and Misfits 5/5 stars!

Thank you Netgalley and Herald Press for a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.



Follow my blog with Bloglovin

Leave a Reply


  • I am that person that sees something she likes and has to make it. Wire wrapped rings ... they are the work of a beginner but they were fun to play with!
  • Flu shots have us feeling rather “eh”. It’s a perfect day to let our imaginations explore different lands in different times. 💚🦕
  • Tomorrow we turn 3. Tonight we stomp and roar. 💚🦕
  • It’s the perfect day to cozy up in our pajamas, drink hot cocoa and snuggle up for a movie. But first we vote. The reasons why are countless but this little girl - she’s my number one. 💙
  • I’m pretty sure that I’m looking forward to the kiddo’s 3rd birthday more than she! With the exception of a few clothes and a book, I made her entire birthday gift by hand and it was such a rewarding experience. I hope she loves it as much as I have loved making it for her. And to finish off her little play world, her Nanny gifted her this gorgeous @grimmswoodentoys rainbow. Now it feels complete! I can’t wait to see what stories she creates here! 💕
  • It’s no wonder why autumn is my favorite. 🧡🍂
  • Today was a gorgeous day - perfect weather for parks, feeding the ducks & swans, looking for spiders and collecting leaves! Little miss and her buddy spent hours giggling, playing and just being kiddos. 🧡
  • when you find the perfect one.
It looks like pies, soups, bread and baked seeds are in our very near future!
Today our little family visited our favorite autumn spot @agafarms - hayrides, pumpkin picking, gorgeous fall trees and the kindest people you could ever meet.
  • This weekend we made it to the @parenfaire with @stephaniekemler and her lovely family! Little miss had a wonderful time showing off her fairy wings and making new discoveries. Of course, in typical fashion, she constantly wandered off the path to check out the trees and play in the dirt. What can I say? 🤷🏻‍♀️ This kid loves what she loves!
  • Breakfast poetry, practicing our flying, feeding the ducks, spending time with wonderful friends, stories & extra cuddles and closing out the evening with a Beach Boys dance party. That is a day well spent! 🧡
  • We don’t mind a little rain. Soggy weather is just a perfect excuse to put on our boots and splash around in the biggest, muddiest puddles we can find! Today, the deer even got some special treats from little miss.🧡
  • Little miss is absolutely smitten with spiders🕷. She is constantly on the lookout and has adopted her very own (imaginary) pet spider named Itsy.
I thought it might be fun to create a little spider play for those rainy days and also introduce her to one of her daddy’s books from his childhood.